My parents had two forms of punishment I could remember, and they changed when they got older. The first thing my parents used to make me do when I was little was “stand in the corner.” I wasn’t sent to my room, most of the time that was better than sticking around and hearing them complain. Instead, I was put in a corner, forced to face the corner with my nose to the wall, and they would continue on with a meal. I had stand AT ATTENTION at all times, and if I leaned or shrugged I had to start the time over. It was a physical punishment, and it was fine, never abusive or anything, but you can only make a kid stand for so long. It also required them to be there to check on me. It was embarrassing because the entire family was watching you stand around looking dumb.
When I got older, and they were working longer hours, they moved to using a written punishment that really sucked when I was grounded. Back when I was still able to be grounded, they would write out a tremendously long sentence, then make me copy it hundreds or thousands of times to earn back my freedom. This is my most lasting memory of punishment. Hearing the phrase “Do you want sentences?” was terrifying. It also killed my hands, killed any desire to use cursive (Writing words in a block down the page was faster), and wasted tons of my free time.
There is a student in our school who is notoriously awful. The number of times he has passed his vocabulary tests on his first try could be counted on one hand, and he has been attending this school for three years. He’s foul mouthed sexist bully, and has the attention span of a fly. In class, if you don’t keep poking his book and telling him what and where to write, he’ll zone off and be behind in classes that are far below his age range. He’s just that bad student every school has that sticks around because their parents don’t want to deal with him. He’s there all day long doing homework and harassing the secretaries trying to get them to let him go home earlier. If he didn’t spend so much time at school, he’d have plenty of time to do his homework at home, but he’s never actually thought that far ahead.
Anyway, I don’t teach him anymore, but I hear stories from my foreign coworker. I don’t know what finally set my coworker off, but he’s had about as much as one person can stand of this horrible student. My coworker took him out of class and made up a unique punishment with the help of the secretary. It seemed almost inspired by my father.
My coworker made the boy write, in Korean, an essay two pages long about why he should pay attention in class and study hard. The secretary then took the essay, wrote his name on it, and posted it on the wall in the middle of the reception area of the school at eye level for ALL the other students to read. All the other students know this boy is a terrible student. They’ve probably been in class with him at one point or another and leveled up past him if they are good at English in any way.
Having your failing posted up on a wall is a very Korean idea of punishment. The board at school is exclusively reserved for achievements most of the time. If students get into exclusive private middle schools, or get accepted to study abroad, they get their name up on the board. This is the first time an embarrasing “punishment” sort of essay is taking up that space.
I doubt the boy cares, because he unabashedly hates to study, but if he cares one shred about what others think about him, he has to be embarrased that his punishment is on display. I’m not sure if this will have results or not. It’s not a “Scarlet Letter” or a Tattoo to tell people their crimes, but it’s as harsh a form of public embarrasment you’ll find at our school.